Seriously, I think Purim is more of a people's rebellion story, and Passover is more the story of a single man (Moses) standing against oppression.
Russ Roberts
· 2 years ago
Joe,
You can also interpret Purim as the story of one man refusing to acknowledge the authority of the state, but I take your point. Then again, Moses is merely God's instrument through most of the Passover story so your comment about God is actually on the mark. You might enjoy The Dawn by Yoram Hazony. It's a superb thought-provoking interpretation of the Book of Esther.
David
· 2 years ago
"Revolution" is not the word that comes to mind when considering the Exodus. Did my great grandparents revolt against the Czar when they left Eastern Europe for the USA? I would use the term "revealed preference" but there's that pesky issue of the Golden Calf.
josh
· 2 years ago
The first time? I doubt it.
Theres a good chance the whole sequence of events didn't take place at all.
Russ Roberts
· 2 years ago
Josh,
I should have said the first recorded episode of popular rebellion.
A lot of people thought it did happen, including the Pilgrims, the Founding Fathers and American slaves, all of whom found it inspiring. The influence of the Exodus has been profound whether you accept it as fact or not.
All Comments
Yeah, but God did all the work!
Seriously, I think Purim is more of a people's rebellion story, and Passover is more the story of a single man (Moses) standing against oppression.
Joe,
You can also interpret Purim as the story of one man refusing to acknowledge the authority of the state, but I take your point. Then again, Moses is merely God's instrument through most of the Passover story so your comment about God is actually on the mark. You might enjoy The Dawn by Yoram Hazony. It's a superb thought-provoking interpretation of the Book of Esther.
"Revolution" is not the word that comes to mind when considering the Exodus. Did my great grandparents revolt against the Czar when they left Eastern Europe for the USA? I would use the term "revealed preference" but there's that pesky issue of the Golden Calf.
The first time? I doubt it.
Theres a good chance the whole sequence of events didn't take place at all.
Josh,
I should have said the first recorded episode of popular rebellion.
A lot of people thought it did happen, including the Pilgrims, the Founding Fathers and American slaves, all of whom found it inspiring. The influence of the Exodus has been profound whether you accept it as fact or not.